Aihe: Worlds 05

[Ilm]

Tän on varmaan joku muukin huomannu, mutta eikö karstenin ja morin toisessa finaali pelissä tapahdu virhe? "Frank untapped, played Kagemaro, and used his last mana to blow everything up. Mori cast a Seedborn Muse and used it to untap at the beginning of Karsten's next turn, which was locked down by Yosei." Kun yosein ability on triggeröitynyt, niin eihän mori silloin voi untapata seedborn musella, koska karstenilla ei ole untap steppiä vai olenko väärässä?

[malin]

http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=mtgevent/worlds05/fin

And then things got strange. As the players were shuffling up for Game 4, Head Judge Sheldon Menery informed the players that it been realized that a mistake may have occurred in Game 2. During that game, Mori had used his Seedborn Muse's ability on a turn when Frank Karsten had to skip his untap step due to a Yosei effect.

However, since Karsten skipped his untap step, Seedborn Muse wouldn't have had a chance to untap Mori's lands, and Mori ended up using some of those untapped lands to cast Congregation at Dawn at the end of Karsten's turn. The match was put on hold and the judging staff reviewed the video of the event to confirm that this is what had happened.

On the video, it was clear this had occurred. The ruling was that, because everybody involved had missed it, it had to be allowed to stand. Mori was given a procedural warning because it is his responsibility to know how his cards work, and we were off to Game 4.