Aihe: SoM draft recorder, aika helppo draft(?) mut pari kyseenalaista pickiä

[Anssi]

Useimmissa oon kyllä aika varma että oma picki on oikea, mutta erityisesti toi 2. Galvanizer vs. Tempered Steel ja Argentum Armor vs. Turn to Slag saattoi olla vääriä. Punaiselta olis varmaan myös voinut teoriassa vaihtaa pois jossain välissä, ajattelin jotenkin vaan että punainen on pakassa ja siellä pysyy.

Event #: 2006171
Time:    1/21/2011 7:34:27 PM
Players:
    Tularis
    shufflerpwned
    OutofAngst
--> Anssi A
    MJMReaper
    Doctor_Robert
    fallzmq
    Jasperov
 
------ SOM ------
 
Pack 1 pick 1:
    Shatter
    Untamed Might
    Oxidda Daredevil
    Alpha Tyrranax
    Psychic Miasma
    Bladed Pinions
    Twisted Image
    Moriok Replica
    Heavy Arbalest
    Myrsmith
    Razorfield Thresher
    Scoria Elemental
    Mountain
--> Molten-Tail Masticore
    Scrapdiver Serpent
 
Pack 1 pick 2:
    Shape Anew
--> Embersmith
    Leaden Myr
    Trigon of Rage
    Wall of Tanglecord
    Tel-Jilad Fallen
    Salvage Scout
    Whitesun's Passage
    Glint Hawk
    Auriok Sunchaser
    Accorder's Shield
    Saberclaw Golem
    Swamp
    Fume Spitter
 
Pack 1 pick 3:
    Perilous Myr
    Culling Dais
    Turn Aside
    Vulshok Heartstoker
    Alpha Tyrranax
    Vigil for the Lost
    Psychic Miasma
    Dispense Justice
    Withstand Death
    Razorfield Thresher
    Scoria Elemental
    Mountain
--> Etched Champion
 
Pack 1 pick 4:
--> Copper Myr
    Necrogen Censer
    Copperhorn Scout
    Dross Hopper
    Carrion Call
    Tel-Jilad Defiance
    Nihil Spellbomb
    Disperse
    Liquimetal Coating
    Island
    Fulgent Distraction
    Scrapdiver Serpent
 
Pack 1 pick 5:
    Plated Seastrider
    Ghalma's Warden
    Contagious Nim
    Iron Myr
    Ferrovore
    Gold Myr
    Soliton
    Carapace Forger
    Flesh Allergy
--> Chrome Steed
    Forest
 
Pack 1 pick 6:
    Memnite
    Sky-Eel School
    Contagious Nim
--> Silver Myr
    Throne of Geth
    Strider Harness
    Auriok Sunchaser
    Auriok Replica
    Clone Shell
    Forest
 
Pack 1 pick 7:
    Halt Order
    Kuldotha Rebirth
    Copperhorn Scout
    Grafted Exoskeleton
    Auriok Replica
--> Panic Spellbomb
    Disperse
    Swamp
    Fulgent Distraction
 
Pack 1 pick 8:
    Ezuri's Archers
    Assault Strobe
    Corrupted Harvester
    Vigil for the Lost
    Relic Putrescence
    Soul Parry
    Plains
--> Memoricide
 
Pack 1 pick 9:
    Alpha Tyrranax
    Psychic Miasma
--> Twisted Image
    Razorfield Thresher
    Scoria Elemental
    Mountain
    Scrapdiver Serpent
 
Pack 1 pick 10:
    Shape Anew
    Salvage Scout
    Whitesun's Passage
--> Auriok Sunchaser
    Saberclaw Golem
    Swamp
 
Pack 1 pick 11:
    Turn Aside
    Vigil for the Lost
--> Razorfield Thresher
    Scoria Elemental
    Mountain
 
Pack 1 pick 12:
    Copperhorn Scout
    Island
    Fulgent Distraction
--> Scrapdiver Serpent
 
Pack 1 pick 13:
--> Ghalma's Warden
    Ferrovore
    Forest
 
Pack 1 pick 14:
--> Auriok Sunchaser
    Forest
 
Pack 1 pick 15:
--> Fulgent Distraction
 
------ SOM ------
 
Pack 2 pick 1:
    Grasp of Darkness
    Blight Mamba
    Vault Skyward
    Blackcleave Goblin
    Abuna Acolyte
    Corrupted Harvester
    Blunt the Assault
    Putrefax
    Sunspear Shikari
--> Snapsail Glider
    Vulshok Replica
    Echo Circlet
    Auriok Replica
    Liquimetal Coating
    Swamp
 
Pack 2 pick 2:
    Melt Terrain
    Necrogen Censer
    Copperhorn Scout
    Blackcleave Goblin
    Golem Foundry
    Strider Harness
    Loxodon Wayfarer
    Barbed Battlegear
    Vedalken Certarch
--> Arrest
    Molder Beast
    Exsanguinate
    Island
    Myr Reservoir
 
Pack 2 pick 3:
    Wing Puncture
    Shatter
    Steady Progress
    Golem's Heart
    Sylvok Lifestaff
    Loxodon Wayfarer
    Carapace Forger
    Bleak Coven Vampires
    Bellowing Tanglewurm
    Horizon Spellbomb
    Stoic Rebuttal
    Island
--> Myr Galvanizer
 
Pack 2 pick 4:
    Untamed Might
    Seize the Initiative
    Oxidda Daredevil
    Tel-Jilad Defiance
    Bladed Pinions
--> Sylvok Lifestaff
    Lifesmith
    Moriok Replica
    Tainted Strike
    Golden Urn
    Mountain
    Asceticism
 
Pack 2 pick 5:
    Vector Asp
    Wing Puncture
--> Vulshok Heartstoker
    Goblin Gaveleer
    Twisted Image
    Vedalken Certarch
    Darksteel Myr
    Molder Beast
    Relic Putrescence
    Stoic Rebuttal
    Island
 
Pack 2 pick 6:
    Assault Strobe
    Ichor Rats
    Vault Skyward
    Blackcleave Goblin
    Instill Infection
--> Gold Myr
    Snapsail Glider
    Echo Circlet
    Soul Parry
    Forest
 
Pack 2 pick 7:
    Contagious Nim
    Leaden Myr
    Trigon of Infestation
    Moriok Reaver
    Ferrovore
--> Silver Myr
    Throne of Geth
    Bleak Coven Vampires
    Forest
 
Pack 2 pick 8:
    Blistergrub
    Golem's Heart
    Whitesun's Passage
    Accorder's Shield
    Scoria Elemental
    Trigon of Mending
    Swamp
--> Ogre Geargrabber
 
Pack 2 pick 9:
    Vault Skyward
    Abuna Acolyte
    Corrupted Harvester
    Blunt the Assault
    Echo Circlet
--> Liquimetal Coating
    Swamp
 
Pack 2 pick 10:
    Melt Terrain
    Copperhorn Scout
    Golem Foundry
    Loxodon Wayfarer
    Island
--> Myr Reservoir
 
Pack 2 pick 11:
    Wing Puncture
    Steady Progress
    Golem's Heart
--> Loxodon Wayfarer
    Island
 
Pack 2 pick 12:
    Seize the Initiative
--> Oxidda Daredevil
    Golden Urn
    Mountain
 
Pack 2 pick 13:
--> Twisted Image
    Relic Putrescence
    Island
 
Pack 2 pick 14:
    Vault Skyward
--> Echo Circlet
 
Pack 2 pick 15:
--> Forest
 
------ SOM ------
 
Pack 3 pick 1:
--> Glint Hawk Idol
    Lumengrid Drake
    Ferrovore
    Thrummingbird
    Furnace Celebration
    Silver Myr
    Riddlesmith
    Cystbearer
    Salvage Scout
    Glint Hawk
    Genesis Wave
    Tainted Strike
    Screeching Silcaw
    Tumble Magnet
    Swamp
 
Pack 3 pick 2:
    Plated Seastrider
    Kuldotha Rebirth
    Ichorclaw Myr
    Razor Hippogriff
    Riddlesmith
    Blunt the Assault
    Turn to Slag
    Flight Spellbomb
    Panic Spellbomb
    Origin Spellbomb
    Disperse
    Plains
--> Argentum Armor
    Fulgent Distraction
 
Pack 3 pick 3:
    Plated Seastrider
    Trigon of Infestation
    Ichorclaw Myr
    Goblin Gaveleer
    Blunt the Assault
    Auriok Edgewright
    Snapsail Glider
--> Turn to Slag
    Relic Putrescence
    Flight Spellbomb
    Palladium Myr
    Stoic Rebuttal
    Island
 
Pack 3 pick 4:
    Neurok Invisimancer
    Oxidda Daredevil
    Tempered Steel
    Blistergrub
    Bleak Coven Vampires
    Withstand Death
    Moriok Replica
    Screeching Silcaw
    Razorfield Thresher
    Golden Urn
    Mountain
--> Myr Galvanizer
 
Pack 3 pick 5:
    Oxidda Daredevil
    Barrage Ogre
    Tel-Jilad Defiance
    Wall of Tanglecord
    Trigon of Thought
    Whitesun's Passage
    Withstand Death
    Neurok Replica
    Screeching Silcaw
--> Chrome Steed
    Forest
 
Pack 3 pick 6:
    Necropede
    Soliton
    Auriok Sunchaser
    Auriok Edgewright
    Grafted Exoskeleton
    Auriok Replica
    Razorverge Thicket
--> Origin Spellbomb
    Forest
    Scrapdiver Serpent
 
Pack 3 pick 7:
    Vector Asp
    Kuldotha Rebirth
    Vault Skyward
    Copperhorn Scout
    Thrummingbird
    Alpha Tyrranax
--> Lifesmith
    Glimmerpost
    Island
 
Pack 3 pick 8:
    Melt Terrain
--> Blade-Tribe Berserkers
    Blackcleave Goblin
    Golem Foundry
    Bonds of Quicksilver
    Blunt the Assault
    Loxodon Wayfarer
    Mountain
 
Pack 3 pick 9:
    Lumengrid Drake
    Thrummingbird
--> Silver Myr
    Riddlesmith
    Salvage Scout
    Screeching Silcaw
    Swamp
 
Pack 3 pick 10:
    Kuldotha Rebirth
    Blunt the Assault
--> Flight Spellbomb
    Disperse
    Plains
    Fulgent Distraction
 
Pack 3 pick 11:
    Goblin Gaveleer
    Blunt the Assault
    Relic Putrescence
--> Stoic Rebuttal
    Island
 
Pack 3 pick 12:
    Neurok Invisimancer
    Razorfield Thresher
--> Golden Urn
    Mountain
 
Pack 3 pick 13:
    Whitesun's Passage
--> Withstand Death
    Forest
 
Pack 3 pick 14:
    Forest
--> Scrapdiver Serpent
 
Pack 3 pick 15:
--> Island

[Nastaboi]

Muutamassa kohdassa olisin varmasti pikannut eri tavalla. En sano, että omani ovat oikeampia, mutta luettelen merkittävimmät ihan vain vertailun vuoksi. Tästä nopeasti lukiessa ei tietenkään näe curvea eikä äijä- ja faksicounttia samalla tavalla kuin draftatessa, mikä vaikuttaa valintoihin.

P2p3: Tässä olisi varmastikin Shatter päätynyt pinooni. Varmaan Lifestaffinkin olisin ottanut Galvanizerin yli.
P2p8: Accorder's Shield
P2p9: Coating on varmaan OK, mutta itse tykkään Abuna Acolytesta.
P3p2: Razor Hippogriff
P3p4: En olisi Tempered Steeliä pystynyt pässäämään.


EDIT: Missasin Perilous Myrin kolmospussista, se tietty kans.

[Farseer]

Tässä omia mietteitä, hieman vaikeata tosin ekan pussin jälkeen pitää mielessä miten curve ja pickit vaikuttavat:

p1p3: Perilous Myr
Perustelu: SSS-draftissa Champion ei juuri loista. Poikaisa lappu toki, mutta shokkiMyyrä on vain parempi (tokassa pussissa tuli vielä Reservoirikin, nam)

p1p5: Iron Myr
On-color myr (tai vaikka Carace Forger vihreän myyrän jälkeen) yli 4 manan 4/4:n, kun ne tuppaavat kiertämään (ja 4 manalta löytyy 5/5:siakin unkkeina)

p1p6: Mahdollisesti Memnite, varsinkin jos p1p5 olisi ollut myyrä

p3p2: Mahdollisesti Hippogriff, armor maksaa ihan pirusti vaikka mauton vehje onkin

p3p3: Palladium Myr
Lihaa ja kallista equipmenttia löytyy, on myös MYYRÄ!

p3p4: Tempered Steel
Ollaan valkoisella, joten parempi varsinkin ilman Palladiumia jne.

p3p5: Barrage Ogre
Monipuolisempi kuin hevonen

Noissa tietty aina miettimisen varaa, mutta kyllähän noilla pusseilla pakasta tulee vähemmälläkin ihan sairas.